Biology – Quantitative Biology – Quantitative Methods
Scientific paper
2011-04-27
Biology
Quantitative Biology
Quantitative Methods
Scientific paper
To investigate possible errors, length-weight parameters from FishBase.org were used to graph length-weight curves for six different species: channel catfish, black crappie, largemouth bass, rainbow trout, flathead catfish, and lake trout along with the standard weight curves (Anderson and Neumann 1996, Bister et al. 2000). Parameters noted as doubtful by FishBase were excluded. For each species, variations in curves were noted, and the minimum and maximum predicted weights for a 30 cm long fish were compared with each other and with the standard weight for that length. For lake trout, additional comparisons were made between the parameters and study details reported in FishBase.org for 6 of 8 length-weight relationships and those reported in the reference (Carlander 1969) for those 6 relationships. In all species studied, minimum and maximum curves produced with the length-weight parameters at FishBase.org are notably different from each other, and in many cases predict weights that are clearly absurd. For example, one set of parameters predicts a 30 cm rainbow trout weighing 44 g. For 30 cm length, the range of weights (relative to the standard weight) for each species are: channel catfish (31.4% to 193.1%), black crappie (54.0% to 149.0%), largemouth bass (28.8% to 130.4%), rainbow trout (14.9% to 113.4%), flathead catfish (29.3% to 250.7%), and lake trout (44.0% to 152.7%). Length-weight tables at FishBase.org are not generally reliable and the on-line database contains dubious parameters. Assurance of quality probably will require a systematic review with more careful and comprehensive methods than those currently employed.
Cole-Fletcher Simeon
Courtney Michael
Marin-Salcedo Lucas
Rana Ajaya
No associations
LandOfFree
Errors in Length-weight Parameters at FishBase.org does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this scientific paper.
If you have personal experience with Errors in Length-weight Parameters at FishBase.org, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Errors in Length-weight Parameters at FishBase.org will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFWR-SCP-O-476346