Preliminary Compositional Comparisons of H-Chondrite Falls to Antarctic H-Chondrite Populations

Details Preliminary Compositional Comparisons of H-Chondrite Falls to Antarctic H-Chondrite Populations Preliminary Compositional Comparisons of H-Chondrite Falls to Antarctic H-Chondrite Populations

Jul 1993

adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?bibcode=1993metic..28..377k&link_type=abstract

Meteoritics, vol. 28, no. 3, volume 28, page 377

Other

Antarctic Meteorites, Chondrites, H Chondrites, Meteorites, Composition, Neutron Activation Analysis, Parent Bodies, Petrography, Weathering

Scientific paper

In a series of papers [e.g., 1,2], Lipschutz and co-workers compared trace- element RNAA data from Antarctic and non-Antarctic H4-6 chondrites and concluded that the two populations have significantly different concentrations of several trace elements including Co, Se, and Sb. They interpreted their data as indicating that these Antarctic H chondrites form different populations than observed H falls and may have originated in separate parent bodies. Recent work by Sears and co-workers [e.g., 3] has shown that there seem to be distinct populations of Antarctic H chondrites, distinguishable on the bases of induced thermoluminescence (TL) peak temperature, metallographic cooling rate, and cosmic ray exposure age. They showed that a group of Antarctic H chondrites having abnormally high induced TL peak temperatures (>=190 degrees C) also has cosmic ray exposure ages <20 Ma (mostly ~8 Ma) and fast metallographic cooling rates (~100 K/Ma). Another group having induced TL peak temperatures <190 degrees C has exposure ages >20 Ma and slower cooling rates (~10-20 K/Ma). We studied 24 H4-6 chondrites from Victoria Land (including 12 previously analyzed by the Lipschutz group) by optical microscopy and electron microprobe. Many of the Antarctic H chondrites studied by Lipschutz and co- workers are unsuitable for proper compositional comparisons with H chondrite falls: Four are very weathered, five are extensively shocked, and two are extensively brecciated. Furthermore, at least five of the samples contain solar-wind gas (and hence are regolith breccias) [4]. These samples were rejected because of possible compositional modification by secondary processes. For our INAA study we chose a suite of relatively unweathered and unbrecciated Antarctic H chondrites (including nine from the Lipschutz set): ALHA 77294 (H5, S3); ALHA 79026 (H5, S3); ALHA 79039 (H5, S3); ALHA 80131 (H5, S3); ALHA 80132 (H5, S4); ALHA 81037 (H6, S3); EETA 79007 (H5, S4); LEW 85320 (H6, S4); LEW 85329 (H6, S3); RKPA 78002 (H5, S2); and RKPA 78004 (H4, S4). Single samples were each analyzed for 27 elements. Only four of our samples have been analyzed by TL. Concentrations of siderophile elements (Fe, Co, Ni, Ga, As, Au) in the Antarctic H chondrites tend to scatter more than those of 24 H falls studied in replicate at UCLA. This is probably due in part to the fact that replicate samples of the Antarctic chondrites have not yet been analyzed. The median concentrations of siderophile elements also tend to be slightly lower in Antarctic H chondrites, although 95% confidence intervals on the medians overlap with those of H falls for every element. Concentration ranges and median values of two chalcophile elements, Se and Zn, are nearly identical between the Antarctic H chondrites and H falls. Kolmogorov-Smirnov two-tailed tests on these elements show no significant differences between the two populations. Three of the elements analyzed in this study (Co, Se, Sb) are among those reported to vary significantly between Antarctic H chondrites and H falls by Dennison and Lipschutz [1], who found that median concentrations of these elements were slightly higher in Antarctic H chondrites. As noted earlier, we determined slightly lower median concentrations for Co and Sb in Antarctic H chondrites than in H falls; median Se concentrations were identical. The slightly lower median concentration values that we found for siderophile elements in general are probably indicative of a slight weathering loss of metal. Based on our compositional data, the Victoria Land H chondrites and non-Antarctic H falls do not require derivation from separate parent populations. References: [1] Dennison J. E. and Lipschutz M. E. (1987) GCA, 51, 741-754. [2] Lipschutz M. E. and Samuels S. M. (1991) GCA, 55, 19-34. [3] Benoit P. H. and Sears D. W. G. (1993) Icarus, 101, 188-200. [4] Schultz L. et al. (1991) GCA, 55, 59-66.

Affiliated with

Also associated with

No associations

Rating

Preliminary Compositional Comparisons of H-Chondrite Falls to Antarctic H-Chondrite Populations does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this scientific paper.

If you have personal experience with Preliminary Compositional Comparisons of H-Chondrite Falls to Antarctic H-Chondrite Populations, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Preliminary Compositional Comparisons of H-Chondrite Falls to Antarctic H-Chondrite Populations will most certainly appreciate the feedback.

Rate now

Comments { 0 }

Profile ID: LFWR-SCP-O-1072358